Weapons Ban Makes No Sense Because Power Hates Submitting to Logic

Economist, Megan McArdle has written a valuable and yet problematic piece for the Daily Beast, “Just Say No to Dumb Gun Laws.” Since I think all gun laws are dumb, or at least illegal and thus damaging to the social order of the United States, I could technically agree with her title. But I’d be happier if she had simplified it by replacing the word, “Dumb” with the word, “All.”

But the real problem on display in McArdle’s brief essay is her assumption that anyone cares whether or not a law makes sense. Now maybe McArdle really knows better. Maybe she is trying to point out the insane psychology that motivates the making of new laws by trying to hold up a simple and reasonable claim so that the psychotic nature of policy making will be more visible. Maybe. But she comes across as simply naïve.

McArdle points out that the difference between the “assault weapons” that would be banned and the ones that would not be banned are virtually the same. A pistol grip does not make a pump action shotgun more lethal. There was no sudden increase in crime when the ban ended in 2004. So while the laws would have no effect on crime or death rates, it would be expensive to implement. “A law that has no obvious benefit, but substantial regulatory cost, just obviously flunks this basic cost-benefit analysis.”

I disagree. I think a law that makes no sense, that requires more spending and more government agents, is a law that is especially attractive to those in power. We see it in the TSA. We see it in Obamacare. Politicians like to vote for self-contradictory nonsense that forces the populace to dance to a constantly changing and unpredictable tune.

The point here is that power justifies itself in the desires of most people. As O’Brien told Winston in George Orwell’s 1984: “The Party seeks power entirely for its own sake. We are not interested in the good of others; we are interested solely in power. Not wealth or luxury or long life or happiness: only power, pure power.”


This may seem cynical, but I don’t see why it is not credible. No, not everyone is given over to the lust after power, but what sorts of people are more likely to seek power and hold onto it? Common sense says it will be the people who want it the most and who will do whatever they have to do to acquire that power. The people who should not have it are the ones who will most strive for it.

And such people don’t want to answer to logic, or economics, or math. They want what they want and power means the ability to ignore any other consideration. Orwell goes on to put in the mouth of the villain a statement couple of sentences that seem to describe the TSA and then our educational-industrial complex: “Power is in inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is in tearing human minds to pieces and putting them together again in new shapes of your own choosing.”

McArdle writes that, “we should not have largely symbolic laws that require real and large regulatory interventions.” That depends on who is “we.” For us the rulers, us the “policy makers,” a largely symbolic law that requires real and large regulatory interventions is usually a rush. It works like a drug. Here are all the little people with their guns, and they have to do what we say, carry the permits we mandate, pay the fees we demand, and make sure they are complying with our (usually contradictory) laws.

The cost/benefit failure isn’t a bug; for our political class, it is a feature.



Single Post Navigation

Comments are closed.


Honor America

China Daily Mail

News and Opinions From Inside China


GOLD is the money of the KINGS, SILVER is the money of the GENTLEMEN, BARTER is the money of the PEASANTS, but DEBT is the money of the SLAVES!!!

My Opinion My Vote

America needs saving

America: Going Full Retard...

Word: They are acting. They are creating. They are framing their reality around you. And we … we bark at the end of our leashes. Our ambition for freedumb is at the end of our leash.


The greatest site in all the land!

I am removing this blog and I have opened a new one at:

Reclaim Our Republic

Knowledge Is Power


— Corporate whistle blower and workers’ comp claimant, now TARGETED INDIVIDUAL, whose claims exposed Misdeeds after the murder of my husband on their jobsite by the U.S. NWO Military Industrial Complex-JFK Warned Us—

Linux Power

Just another weblog

The ‘red pill’ and its opposite, ‘blue pill,‘ are pop culture terms that have become symbolic of the choice between blissful ignorance (blue) and embracing the sometimes-painful truth of reality (red). It’s time for America to take the red pill and wake up from the fog of apathy.

The Mad Jewess

Mirror Site For Reflection

Freedom Is Just Another Word...

Rules?? What Are rules? I don't need no stinking rules!!!

sharia unveiled

illuminating minds


Sudden, unexplained, unattended death and a families search for answers


TGR Intelligence Briefing | Sign up for newsletter to receive notifications | Visit us at

Dedicated to freedom in our lifetimes

News You May Have Missed

News you need to know to stay informed


Making the web a better place

%d bloggers like this: